Return to the Table logo banner Dinner with Caterina
July 17, 2025

The Ice Cream Challenge

Why One Pint Is Better Than a Half Gallon

The secret to eating well — isn't about cutting things out. It's about choosing food with genuine flavor and high-quality ingredients, so you feel truly satisfied.

This is a cornerstone of the Mediterranean way of eating.

To see for yourself, take a taste test. Try one ingredient next to another. Notice the difference in flavor, texture, and how you feel afterward.

It applies to everything — ice cream included!

To experience it, take the Ice Cream Challenge.

IMG 0770
Gelato in Torino

Buy two kinds of ice cream:
– One high-quality pint that costs $7 or $8 — the kind made with real ingredients, not artificial ones.

IMG 5591
Simple ingredients ...
IMG 4938
... just the way good ice cream should be.

– One big tub or half-gallon that costs less — maybe $4 or $5 — made with fillers and more artificial ingredients.

IMG 5596
Ingredients we can do without.

Try them both.

What you'll notice right away is that the expensive pint tastes like something worth eating. The flavor is more pronounced. It blooms in your mouth and tickles every taste bud. The sweetness is balanced, not cloying. A few spoonfuls feel like a moment of luxury. It tastes like homemade.

IMG 9670
Making gelato

Then taste the cheaper one. You might like it at first, but keep going. The sweetness builds — and is addictive. The flavors feel flat and artificial. And somehow, it's easier to keep eating — because your brain’s still searching for the satisfaction it didn’t get the first time. Not to mention the sugar hook.

When I eat something that’s missing real flavor, I want to take another bite and another, hoping to be satisfied, which never happens. So I end up eating more in the end, without the pleasure.

And that’s a secret to eating well and maintaining your good health and weight: high-quality food is less addictive because it's more satisfying. It doesn't leave you chasing something that isn't there. In ice cream, the chocolate tastes like chocolate. The caramel tastes like it was actually made with butter and sugar, not in a lab.

Now back to the pint.

It may seem small, but it's more than enough. For a family of four, one pint is enough for three desserts — that's all you need when it's really, really good. Serve a bit after dinner and enjoy.

IMG 6634 1
Gelato with berry coulis.

Eating a small serving of ice cream at dinner is a naturally good choice. The big bowl of cheap ice cream two hours after dinner is loaded with calories. When you eat it too late, your digestion is already well underway. That habit not only adds more calories than you need, it also disrupts your body's natural rhythm and digestive process.

Take the ice cream challenge and see. It only costs around $8, and you get to eat ice cream twice!

Quality isn't more expensive — it's less in the end.

And over the long term, quality saves your health too. Fewer calories and chemicals = fewer diet plans, or fixes (maybe medications), later on.

Choosing better ingredients — and superior flavor — gives you more enjoyment, not less. You're not missing out. You're actually getting more of what you wanted in the first place: pleasure, satisfaction, and something worth slowing down for.

Next? How about taking the chocolate challenge?

IMG 9333
Michel Cluizel chocolate.
IMG 6986
Take a taste test with "Nutella" spread and chocolate chips too.
IMG 1569
And hot chocolate — it's just melted chocolate and milk!
I provide links to products and services I genuinely love and want to share with you. Some of these links may earn me a referral commission at no additional cost to you. This referral fee helps support this site. Thank you for your support!
Caterina DeFalco image for contact page
Ciao for now!
caterina's signature

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Success Stories

  • Now I Have Great Kitchen Intuition!

    "Finding you [has] truly inspired me to cook more and focus on quality ingredients. Strengthening my kitchen intuition has been key, it's how I know to roll leftovers into something new or I can see what I bought and come up with creative solutions.

    As a family, we always valued sitting down together for dinner but now it's done with so much less stress. I can be done with work and still make easy meals . . . amazing quality meals that are thrown together in a short time and we get to enjoy each other!"

    1 2 3 5
  • My Family is Closer Than Ever

    “Your suggestions are so priceless! Thank you for such valuable content. My family is closer than ever, thanks to you!”

  • BRAVO! I'm in!

    “[Caterina is], in 5 steps, hitting all the major points of what works in generational connection across all cultures. Families don’t just happen, they are grown and this is the sweet and lasting way to do that. Bravo and I’m IN!”

  • A Real Game Changer

    "We have made a lot of progress over here under your care. We are now all eating from the same “pot” which I was surprised how much my kids loved. They were so excited when I put the food in the middle of the table. They asked for it the next day, Can we do that special fancy dinner thing where we have a feast? It really is such a better ritual—passing the food around and all sharing from the same platter, a real game changer."

  • Accidental Weight Loss!

    “I don't know if I told you, but I accidentally lost about 8 lbs after cutting out most semi-processed foods!"

Studio One44
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram