Return to the Table logo banner Dinner with Caterina
September 9, 2024

Dinner Stories: Finding Your "Thumbs Up" Dinners

“What’s for dinner?” This question follows us every day, and everywhere. Even during our stay in Florence while my son, Alessio, is taking a design class, I still have to figure out what’s for dinner. 

Wonderful restaurants surround us, but we can’t eat out every night. So I am still cooking dinner most days—for myself and the pickiest of my three children.


IMG 3506
Trattoria down the street from us in Florence

Although I have plenty of ideas, I came across a cookbook in the kitchen here, and I decided to have Alessio flip through it to see what he thought looked good for dinner.

I did this when my kids were little too.  I handed them cookbooks and different colored sticky notes, one for each child, and asked them to mark the recipes that looked good—and not just the desserts!

This simple exercise worked wonders and helped me build what I still call our Family Menu, which is proving to be handy once again. (It also encouraged my kids to practice reading.) When something looked good to them, they learned to check the recipe for “culprits,” like mushrooms or too much spinach, before it earned their sticky note.

The next test for a recipe to get on the Family Menu was the vote. When I made something new, the kids voted on it at dinner using a “Thumbs Up” verdict.

Thumb UpI Love it! This goes on the Menu.

Thumb Up Tilted to the SideIt’s not my favorite, but it’s pretty good. You can put it on the Menu.

Thumb to the SideNeutral. You can put it on the menu, and I will eat it, but I’m not excited about it. 

Thumb Down to the SideI don't care for this, but I will eat it if I have to. Please don't serve it often. These dishes were either ones that I loved and felt would expand my children’s palates, or they were healthy and I felt we needed to have them on the Menu. 

Thumb DownNo Way. You can make it, but I am not going to eat it. If I liked the dish, I tucked these recipes away for now, thinking I’d try again later.


IMG 2739 Edited

If you struggle to come up with dinner ideas that please the whole family, show your kids some cookbooks or recipe sites and have them suggest what looks good. Then vote and add the winners—and the neutrals—to your Family Menu.

You can use these ideas to get input from anyone in your family! 

IMG 9990

If you read my upcoming book, you will also learn how to use a “family-approved” ingredient to prompt a multitude of dinner ideas.

I provide links to products and services I genuinely love and want to share with you. Some of these links may earn me a referral commission at no additional cost to you. This referral fee helps support this site. Thank you for your support!
Caterina DeFalco image for contact page
Ciao for now!
caterina's signature

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Student Success Stories

  • Now I Have Great Kitchen Intuition!

    "Finding you [has] truly inspired me to cook more and focus on quality ingredients. Strengthening my kitchen intuition has been key, it's how I know to roll leftovers into something new or I can see what I bought and come up with creative solutions.

    As a family, we always valued sitting down together for dinner but now it's done with so much less stress. I can be done with work and still make easy meals . . . amazing quality meals that are thrown together in a short time and we get to enjoy each other!"

    1 2 3 5
  • My Family is Closer Than Ever

    “Your suggestions are so priceless! Thank you for such valuable content. My family is closer than ever, thanks to you!”

  • BRAVO! I'm in!

    “[Caterina is], in 5 steps, hitting all the major points of what works in generational connection across all cultures. Families don’t just happen, they are grown and this is the sweet and lasting way to do that. Bravo and I’m IN!”

  • A Real Game Changer

    "We have made a lot of progress over here under your care. We are now all eating from the same “pot” which I was surprised how much my kids loved. They were so excited when I put the food in the middle of the table. They asked for it the next day, Can we do that special fancy dinner thing where we have a feast? It really is such a better ritual—passing the food around and all sharing from the same platter, a real game changer."

  • Accidental Weight Loss!

    “I don't know if I told you, but I accidentally lost about 8 lbs after cutting out most semi-processed foods!"

Studio One44
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram